The annual bathing water classifications have been announced. But what should we take from today’s assessment?
It’s more than just a single issue
The annual bathing water classifications have been announced today. Every year, every designated bathing water is defined in one of four categories. Excellent, Good, Sufficient or Poor. And every year there is generally one issue to blame where standards have declined. Sewage.
But the bathing water classifications highlight just how complex the issue of water quality is. They are misunderstood, misrepresented and help to perpetuate a ‘single-issue’ narrative. Understanding how they’re made, what they’re for and what they tell us is key to broadening the debate beyond the headlines and towards a better approach to protecting our seas.
The privatised water industry is synonymous with the classifications despite having no direct control over how they are made or assessed. But the sentiment is so strong and the narrative so compelling that it’s easy to see why many people believe the water companies alone are responsible for them.
There’s more beneath the surface
Communicating nuance is difficult. We live in a society of absolutes. Blaming a water company when a bathing water drops to the lowest classification, Poor, is easy.
The thing to understand about the bathing water classifications, however, is that they don’t tell anyone about the quality of bathing water at any given moment.
They are the expression of the sum of a rather complicated calculation that uses a rolling four-year data set.
Consequently, the classifications point to a trend. They help us see how a bathing water might be faring in general terms. Not in the moment.
What that means is that each of this year’s classifications is being affected by the data as far back as 2021.
Stuck in class
The Environment Agency tests designated bathing waters every week from May to September. The Bathing Season. Two types of bacteria are measured. Intestinal Enterococci and E-Coli.
The higher the levels of bacteria in any given sample, the closer that bathing water comes to dropping a classification. If the sample is really high, the effect can span the entire four year period. So a bathing water that has had a season’s worth of low bacteria samples taken may still be classified as poor. They are trapped in the calculation. It’s only once the ‘bad’ year falls through the other end that they might improve.
That’s the functional aspect of how the classifications are calculated. They are fed, of course, by what’s in the water.
There are all sorts of ways bacteria can be present. One of which is sewage. But the impact from seabirds, dogs and agriculture can and does show up in the sample record. The run off from our roads after heavy rain shouldn’t be understated either.
Working together is vital
The challenge for the industry is how to communicate on better terms. It’s going to depend upon the strength of its relationships and robust stakeholder engagement.
People’s relationship with the sea is changing and the classifications are likely to follow suit. Now is the perfect time to reset the collective understanding of how and why they work. Clarity is key. Communication is critical.